hide results

    Perfect Town Guide by elumelum

    Version: 1.x | Updated: 07/07/03 | Search Guide | Bookmark Guide

    #                                                 #
    #               ~ Animal Crossing ~               #
    #     Perfect Town Condition/Golden Axe Guide     #
    #            Ver. 1.x updated 7/7/03              #
    #                                                 #
    #           by elumelum, Copyright 2002           #
    #                                                 #
    CONTENTS ('*'s indicate new or updated sections)
    I.      Introduction
            - Disclaimer
            * Version History/Updates
            - Description
            - A Word of Encouragement
    II.     Perfect Town Guidelines
            - Definition of Terms
                    - Exempt and Non-Exempt
                    - Trash
                    - The Well's Messages
                    - The 4 Town Conditions
                    - Adjacent Trees
                    - The Lake
                    - Normal Acres
            - The Checklist
            - The "Scoring System" Idea
            - Helpful Hints
                    - Exempt Acres
                    - Counting Your Trees
                    - Mail-order Axes!
                    - STUMPS
                    - Tips on Growing Trees
                    - Partially-Grown Trees
                    - Weeds
                    - Dead Tree Sprouts as Weeds
                    - Trash
                    - Flowers
    III.    Getting the Golden Axe
            - Keep it up!
            - The Well-Deserved Reward
    IV.     - SPECULATION Central
    	- New or Unconfirmed SPECULATION
    	- Confirmed or Denied Previous SPECULATION
    V.      Wrap Up
    	- Thanks
    	- Copyrights, etc.
    SECTION I:                         Introduction
    This FAQ is for personal use.  You may print out a copy for yourself,
    but please do not distribute it.  You may discuss the information on
    the Internet so long as you give me full credit for it.  Do not excerpt
    from this FAQ without giving me credit.  I've worked hard to make this
    FAQ, and all I ask in return is proper credit for it. See Copyrights, etc.
    in the Wrap Up section for more details.  Enjoy!
    Version History/Updates (* please read *)
    Ver. 1.x (7/8/03):
    I've been away from this for quite some time now, but I just wanted to 
    put up an update saying a few things:
    1) There are several other FAQs out there that finally got the whole thing
    figured out better than I did.  I wanted to thank everybody that helped me
    ("back in the day"), and direct people to look elsewhere, but I thought
    I'd leave this up for posterity's sake.
    2) If you still have trouble with this part of the game, consult the
    GameFAQs board--you should be able to find help there.  I wish I had
    links to the other FAQs (a certain issue of Tips & Tricks magazine had 
    it broken down to a scoring system that was perfect), but I don't.
    3) My e-mail address is gone--I can no longer answer any questions on
    this subject.  Thanks for the ride everybody, even though it kinda ended a
    while back.  The whole thing just got too big for me to handle, but maybe
    I'll write another guide someday!
    Ver. 1.21 (11/29/02):
    This version update is mainly just a massive response to all the e-mails
    I've been getting.  I've been really busy and really sick lately, so I
    haven't had time to research or update, but there's a lot of great info
    right around the corner.  To everybody having trouble getting perfect:
    plant more trees.  Not more than 16 a square, of course, but I'm almost
    positive there's a total number of trees you need to hit.  Also, plant
    more trees in your beach squares, the player square and the well square,
    even if they fail.  It seems like dead trees don't count as weeds, and
    they definitely do count towards your total tree count for as long as
    they exist.
    All of this stuff will be treated in greater detail as soon as I get to
    update--hopefully soon.  Thanks for reading this FAQ and thanks for
    sticking with it!
    Ver. 1.2 (11/04/02):
    Getting around to updating the guide has gotten tougher, as I've had less
    time lately, and more e-mails than ever.  Keep them coming though--all of
    your information is appreciated.
    Perhaps the most important new ideas are about a scoring system and about an
    HRA point requirement.  See SPECULATION Central as well as the first half of
    Section II for more details.
    Another very important update is simply a point of clarification I'll offer
    here: no part of this guide is not final.  Not only are there many things
    about obtaining perfect condition that I don't know (and that I'm working
    on), but also I'm only human, and I make plenty of mistakes.  Even things
    that say CONFIRMED or DENIED are subject to change (see also Word of
    I say this not to shoot myself in the foot or strip away my own validity,
    but only to clarify that this guide can be "wrong" and still be useful.
    I'm a little frustrated at people saying my guide is "wrong", dismissing
    it on those grounds, and then not looking at it again.  Your opinions are
    your own business, but they are also extremely valuable to me.  If you think
    this guide is "wrong", and especially if you have theories on why it's wrong,
    please e-mail me.
    Obviously I can't make everybody go through me as a forum for figuring
    this whole thing out, but I'd like to encourage using this guide as a
    collaborative resource.  Also, please participate in the Perfect Town
    threads on the board.  I may not always be able to check the board, so I might
    have missed something important or useful on there.  There's a lot more good
    stuff being discovered about perfect status then there was even a week ago.
    Sorry for the pocket rant.  On a similar note, the introduction to Section II
    has been updated, and in the Checklist, the word "requirements" has been
    changed to "guidelines".  See Section II for details.
    I've done some grammar and wording fixes as usual, and changed some details
    such as the maximum number of weeds in the Checklist and in the Keep It Up
    section.  I didn't get to proofread this as much as I would have liked, but
    once I start to see many e-mails about the same thing, I know it's time to
    get an update up there, even if it's a little screwy in parts.  ;)
    I'm having a tough time putting everyone's name in the thank you section.
    I'm now getting suggestions from so many people, it's hard to say who found
    anything first.  Thus proper crediting is an issue.  If you think something
    has been miscredited, let me know.  I'll try to put everyone who's been
    helpful in the thank you section in due time.  Also, thanks to everyone for
    being patient and flexible in reading this FAQ--this subject is unusual, so
    I had to write an usual FAQ to suit it.
    * For those of you who've done everything they can and are still stuck, try
    checking the total number of trees in your town and sending it to me.  Also,
    try planting more trees in the beach acres, and see if it helps (see
    SPECULATION Central for details).
    I hope you all find some helpful things in this latest update, and I hope
    that I can find some more concrete info for next time.  Enjoy!
    Ver. 1.11 (11/01/02):
    My e-mail has been broken for a week, so most of your suggestions (if you've
    been sending them) have not made it to me.  Please re-send them!  I still
    have some important things to update in the next version, so if I respond
    and say "Wait for the next version", please don't be offended or take it
    personally--if I'm writing about your problem in the FAQ, I'd rather not
    rewrite the whole solution in an e-mail.  I'll still respond to individual
    questions as best I can.
    Thanks for all of your support!  You all have been great!  Please note that
    aside from this message, nothing about this version has been changed from
    ver 1.1.  See you soon in the next update!
    Ver. 1.1 (10/23/02):
    The most important thing I've found in the last two days has to do with
    weeds: in addition to having an incorrect maximum number, there was much that
    I didn't know at all.  Check the updated checklist and the weeds section for
    more details.  The adjacent trees requirement has been moved to the
    speculation part of the checklist--although it was certainly the last thing
    keeping me from obtaining perfect, some readers (incl. Charizard2000, Russell
    Milligan) insist that they have several pairs of diagonally touching trees
    and they maintain perfect.  Stay tuned as we figure that one out.
    The 3 Town Conditions section has been changed to the 4 Town Conditions
    section--I've discovered a few new messages from the well that point to this.
    I've added a new (and perhaps temporary) section called SPECULATION Central.
    This is where new ideas (whether mine or readers') will go.  Things will get
    moved from here to the appropriate place either after being confirmed, or
    after being there for a while (for one to three updates).  Also, speculation
    from previous versions of the FAQ that have been confirmed or denied will
    find themselves into this area.
    Check out this new section for a couple of important SPECULATIONs about
    flowers and the Well's "imperfect" sight.
    I've also received many, many corrections, most of which were about the
    dump, on which I stand duly corrected.  On a similar note, Section III has
    been updated, as well as speculation/information on exempt squares.
    Last, and certainly least: I fixed some tabs and some formatting issues.
    P.S.  Out of extreme need for this update (and to silence the e-mails about
    the trash) I'm rushing this update out the door a little bit.  Please be
    forgiving if there's any glaring errors, although I don't think there should
    be anything really bad.  There are several great things that I meant to
    put in this version (suggestions about HRA scores, etc.) that will have
    to wait for 1.2.
    Ver. 1.0 (10/19/02):
    -HUGE- UPDATE (and complete 1.0 level FAQ completion):
    Unfortunately, in my first batch of otherwise great and helpful e-mail
    responses from all you readers, there was the Klez virus. Fortunately I've
    wiped it out now, but it took me hours to get fully get rid of it, and I was
    hoping to use that time to update the FAQ.  Note to anyone who suspects they
    have a virus--don't e-mail me until you scan your computer.  All sending me
    viruses will do is anger me and make it harder for me to work to update this
    FAQ for you all.
    Now that that's out of the way, here's a list of most of the additions in
    this large-and-in-charge update:
    -A more detailed explanation of "adjacent trees" was added, which is
    especially important, as it has been causing many people trouble.  The most
    common thing I've seen holding someone back from perfect condition is one
    tree somewhere diagonally touching another.
    Special thanks to Tan Tan and several others for pointing out that I needed
    to flesh that part out.
    -Many sections have been added: check out the new and interesting tips in
    them (including "Dying Sprouts as Weeds?").
    -Thanks to much reader input, the information on flowers and the role they
    play in achieving perfect condition has been fleshed out considerably.
    However, several important details are yet to be confirmed.
    -Perhaps one of the most important updates is the division of the checklist
    into confirmed requirements and speculative requirements.  Speculation about
    requirements and otherwise is extremely valuable to sleuthing out all that
    can be learned about this aspect of the game.
    -Also, on the topic of speculation, SPECULATION labels have been added in
    points where there is information that is very hard to confirm, but that is
    still very important.  Please note that I can't guarantee or back up these
    -I've done some more editing of the general format, fixing of
    79-character-per-line problems (that hyphenation caused one in and of itself),
    and general sprucing up of spelling, grammar, and style.
    -Please visit the updated Thanks section to see all those who are also
    mentioned throughout the document who contributed greatly already within the
    first two days of this FAQs existence.
    Ver. 0.91 (10/18/02):
    Minor corrections (editing, spelling, grammar, names in Thanks section).
    Ver. 0.9 (10/17/02):
    First version--I've researched the information contained within
    for hours upon hours, so most of it is confirmed and correct.
    However, the success of this FAQ will also depend on your input
    to help verify and expand the information.
    The only reason I didn't name this Ver. 1.0 is that information
    on the specific length of time your town must stay "perfect" to
    get the Golden Axe is a very important detail that I haven't
    confirmed yet.
    Future updates: The tailor acre: exempt or not?, more info on
    # of days for Golden Axe, details of receiving the Golden Axe...
    This FAQ is the first full FAQ I've written, and the first that I hope to
    actually distribute on the web.  Having said that, I've gone to great
    lengths to make sure that I knew what I was talking about before I began
    work on this.  I'm writing this FAQ because I've seen many, many posts
    asking for help on the matter (and I've written a few) and only seen cryptic
    or vague answers at best.  That's not to say that the answers were wrong--it
    just seems that many people, even after actually achieving perfect status,
    simply didn't know exactly what the criteria were that needed to be fulfilled.
    Partly due to luck, and partly due to being extremely (in fact, overly)
    thorough, I have come up with solid information on most, if not all of these
    This guide is designed to be a source for quick and easy answers to most
    questions people ask about reaching perfect condition (as determined by the
    wishing well) and about obtaining the golden axe.  In fact, eventually, one
    should be able to use this guide as a checklist in order to help them obtain
    perfect status.
    I am assuming that the reader has a good working knowledge of everyday life
    in Animal Crossing--if you need help with the basics, I suggest checking out
    the GameFAQs Animal Crossing Message Board:
    ...and/or the Beginner's Guide by JTrost on GameFAQs:
    I also recommend getting either Prima's or Nintendo's Strategy Guide for
    this game: my personal choice lies with the Official Nintendo version, as it
    has more detailed information in some sections (more exact fishing and insect
    prime-times, etc.) and the Prima guide has some incorrect information in it.
    However, the Nintendo guide also has a few tidbits of bad information
    (e.g. the sea bass "season"), and the Prima has more speculative information
    if you're looking for that.  Both guides are great, and are very handy
    references with avoidable spoilers.
    A Word of Encouragement
    Okay, so I know that the introduction has gone on for long enough already,
    but I just have to say this: I know that this can be extremely frustrating.
    Especially given that I was drawing charts and running around counting every
    specific type of tree in my town when my roommate got perfect status without
    having to put nearly as much thought in.
    Also, many people complete the checklist as outlined in this guide and then
    e-mail me because the town isn't perfect.  I'm still not sure what the answer
    to these situations is yet, but I'm working on it.  Remember, nothing about
    this guide is final until it says so (see above, in update Ver. 1.2).
    Getting a perfect town can be frustrating.  But it's doable.  Granted, it
    might take a bit of work, but it's doable.  And hopefully this guide will
    make it less stressful.
    SECTION II:             Perfect Town Guidelines
    Follow these rules, and next time you talk to the wishing well, it will
    hopefully tell you that you have a perfect town (very livable!).  If it
    doesn't, there could be one or many things wrong.  If you e-mail me (see
    contact info) with detailed information and if it's useful, I'll update the
    guide ASAP.  Please double check that you've tried everything before
    contacting me.  Also, don't be disappointed if I tell you that I don't know
    the answer to your problem--we're all working together to try to figure this
    all out, and nobody that I know of knows all the workings of the well yet.
    Definition of Terms (please read)
    -The wishing well evaluates your town's condition by assessing most of the
    "acres" (the screens that the town is divided into) in your town.  However,
    some squares don't fall under the scrutiny of the wishing well.  I will refer
    to these squares as "exempt", and to the other squares as "non-exempt".
    -"Trash" refers to boots, cans, and tires that are obtained by fishing (they
    all look the same when dropped), and not to other normal items that may or
    may not be scattered about your landscape (furniture, money sacks, clothes,
    balls, etc.).
    -The Well's Messages
    The Wishing Well has a small handful of answers to the question "How are
    things?"--this is the question you ask the well in order to learn about the
    town's condition.  They are:
    1) The "satisfactory" message:
    'Yes...yes.  Things feel as they should.  This is certainly a satisfactory
    level of prosperity...but with just a little more effort, things could be
    even better.'
    This means that you have most, but not all of the perfect guidelines
    complete.  For me, this meant that I needed to get rid of a couple of
    diagonally touching trees.
    2) The "almost satisfactory" message:
    "Things aren't too bad...but with just a little more care and attention,
    everything would be much, much better."
    This means that you have taken care of most of your weed problems, but there
    are still too many weeds in one acre and/or in your town in general.  Once
    you clear up the weeds, you will wind up with either the "satisfactory"
    message or the "perfect" message, depending on whether the other perfect
    guidelines are met or not.
    3) The "perfect" message:
    "Everything is perfect!  [Your town name] is a very livable place."
    4) The "too many weeds" message:
    "When there are too many weeds...and acres in need of care and attention...
    a town feels very unsettled."
    5) The strange "faring well" message (new as of this update):
    "It appears that things fare well, by and large.  If you were to search out
    areas where there are too many, or not enough, trees...then things would be
    faring even better."
    (Thanks to Rob R., Charles. E./Chezne, Danny L., David N., Duane A. and Steve,
    Erick B., Graham K., Jason M., Jodi W., and several others...)
    I haven't ever recieved this message myself, but several people have written
    to confirm it's existance.  In order to get from this message to the "Yes,
    yes" message, some have replanted trees or removed instances of adjacent
    trees or partly-grown trees, but it seems no-one knows exactly what the deal
    with this is.  Let me know if you have any info on this.
    There are also 6) the "too many trees" message ("Trees are a thing of
    extraordinary beauty but...") and 7) the "too few trees" message ("In areas
    where there is little green...").  The three "too many" / "too few" messages
    are all followed by a message telling you which acre needs work.
    The "too few trees" message means that there's fewer than 9 trees in the
    acre mentioned.  Plant more trees there.
    The "too many trees" message means that there's more than 16 trees in the
    acre mentioned.  Chop down/dig up more trees there.
    The "too many weeds" message (which supplies an acre) means that there's
    more than 3 weeds there.  Pull at least one weed in that acre (you might as
    well pull them all, unless you like to live dangerously with your weeds).
    -The 4 Town Conditions
    There are 4 town conditions: "unsatisfactory" (too few or too many trees in
    one or many acre(s)), "satisfactory" (correct number of trees, but fails one
    of the other requirements on the checklist), "almost satisfactory" (too many
    weeds in one acre and/or in the whole town) and "perfect" (meets all
    conditions described on the checklist below).  See above for explanation of
    the different conditions.
    -"Adjacent" trees are trees that are directly next to each other, even on a
    diagonal.  If a tree is one digging spot up and one to the side from another
    tree, the two trees -ARE- adjacent.  Here's a diagram to help explain:
    If the '0' is any given tree, there must not be trees in the 'x' spaces
    around it.  This diagram shows a diagonally touching pair of trees, which
    will keep you from earning perfect condition:
    If you have confusion as to what the spacing is, try digging a square of
    holes 3x3.  You should notice how they are all evenly spaced.  The spots
    you are able to plant trees in are all in a grid as such.
    A good double-checking idea (as submitted by several readers) is to make sure
    you can run a full circle around the tree in question.
    -The "lake" is the square where the river forms a large pool where there is
    a dock.  As far as I know, every town has one.  It is *not* the holding
    ponds, the isolated bodies of water of which there are several in any given
    -"Normal" acres are acres that are neither beach nor any shop or major town
    point of interest (e.g. police station, Nook's, Museum, and other things as
    marked on the map).
    And now, the moment you've all been waiting for...
    *The Checklist (details follow)*
    Confirmed guidelines:
    - All non-exempt acres must have between 9 and 16 trees (inclusive) in them.
    - All acres must have no more than 3 weeds in them (see Weeds below).
    - You must have fewer than -30- weeds in your whole town.
    - There must be no trash on the ground.
    Speculative guidelines
    - You must have more than or fewer than a certain total number of trees in
      your town. (provided by Rich S. and others)
    - There must be fewer than a certain number of adjacent trees.
    - You must have a certain number of flowers.
      (I'm almost positive that flowers -aren't- required: see Flowers below.)
    - You must have (at least one tree/at least a certain number of trees) in
      *NON-EXEMPT* acres.
      (Recent info suggests at least 3 trees.  Also see SPECULATION Central.)
    This list is growing and being refined every day--by following these
    guidelines, you should be able to get to a perfect town, but there are a few
    sticking points that have yet to be ironed out.  See below for more tips.
    The "Scoring System" Idea:
    It seems that the town's condition (perfect or no) may be based on a scoring
    system rather than a simple checklist.  This seems quite possible, but the
    problem is, it's very very hard to logically deduce whether or not this is
    the case.  It also would be very hard to determine specifics about the
    scoring system, such as how much one criteria (e.g. number of weeds) would be
    'worth' relative to another criteria (e.g. total number of trees).
    Having said this, I think that the perfect condition is much more likely to
    be based on a scoring system than a checklist.  This is why I have changed
    the word "requirements" in the checklist above to "guidelines".  I may never
    be able to flesh out a scoring system, but I may be able to flesh out a list
    of guidelines that will help you earn the right score in a scoring system.
    Helpful Hints:
    Exempt Acres
    You may have as many or as few trees as you like (up to 33, that is)
    in exempt acres.
    Exempt acres are: any and every beach square (including the tailor), the
    player houses (see SPECULATION below), the wishing well (also see
    SPECULATION below), the museum, and the lake.
    (Aldrin Nicholas and others confirm that the lake and the tailor are exempt.)
    Non-exempt acres include the post-office, Nook's, the dump, the police
    station, the train station and of course every other normal acre.
    (The train station has seemed exempt to some, but I'm almost positive it's
    Note that exempt acres are NOT exempt from weed requirements--I have had the
    well complain that there were too many weeds in a beach acre and in the
    museum acre.
    SPECULATION: According to Casey Jones and Kevin Walter, their player-house
    acre and wishing well acre seem to be non-exempt for them.  I think that this
    falls under the new speculative requirement of a minimum number of trees in
    non-exempt acres, but I'm not sure.  Any information on this from anybody
    would be highly appreciated (see contact info below).  I definitely have
    fewer than 6 trees in both of those acres and still have a perfect town.
    Counting Your Trees
    If you are unsure whether or not a tree is in the acre you're in, stand
    directly next to it.  A tree counts towards an acre's tree total if it's
    trunk is in that acre/screen. If you can see a trunk at the top of the
    screen but in order to stand beside it, the screen has to scroll, then the
    tree does not count for the acre below it.  Likewise if you see only the
    top of the tree, it does not count for the acre you're in.
    The same principle works horizontally:  if you see a trunk on the left or
    right edge, but you have to scroll to the next screen to stand above or
    below it, it does not count towards the total of the original acre.
    Fewer than 9 trees:
    Any number of trees 8 and below will result in the "In areas where there
    is little green..." message.  Plant more trees in that acre.
    More than 16 trees:
    Any number of trees 17 and above will result in the "Trees are things of
    extraordinary beauty but..." message.  Chop down/dig up more trees in
    that acre.
    Mail-order Axes!
    If you have a TON of work to do involving cutting down and or replanting
    trees, I highly recommend mail-ordering several axes.  They're cheap, and if
    you end up with more than you need, you can always sell them.  It's
    frustrating to sit down for a major session of tree management only to have
    your axe break and be unable to get a new one.
    GET RID OF THEM.  I could speculate about the maximum number of stumps or on
    how exactly the well looks at them (I know it doesn't like them), but I'm not
    going to.  Why?  Because you might as well dig up these eyesores right after
    you cut something down, at least if you're going for perfect.  If you're not
    going for perfect, you can have all the stumps you want, but why would you
    reading this guide then, anyway?
    Tips on Growing Trees
    As Aldrin Nicholas points out, and as is confirmed by the Nintendo Guide,
    trees take 4 days to grow and fully mature, and 3 days to bear fruit.  Also,
    it is possible for a tree to begin to grow but not ever fully mature--this is
    usually due to a poor planting spot (directly next to other trees, rocks,
    buildings, etc.).  Note that some trees will grow in poor spots, and often
    times, a tree that existed the first time you played will be in a spot that
    you could never plant yourself (those cheaters ;D ).  If a tree has been stuck
    at one stage of it's growth for a long time, it will never mature.
    Also, if you are looking to change the "type" of tree in a certain spot, by
    far the best thing to do is to cut down an existing tree and, after digging
    up the stump but before covering up the hole, plant a new tree in the same
    spot.  The Nintendo Power Guide and many FAQs suggest that this increases
    the chance of having the new tree grow successfully, and I agree with them.
    Ver 1.2: Eric S. suggests not planting tons of new trees too close to each
    other, as it seems to reduce their chances of success.
    Partially-Grown Trees
    The question has been raised about whether partially-grown trees count towards
    the total number of trees for that acre.  I'm almost positive that the answer
    is yes, as simply planting a sprout will increase the tree count for any acre.
    Also, there is speculation that partially-grown trees count against you.  This
    does not seem to be true (see SPECULATION Central).
    It seems that about 5 weeds appear in your town every day.  You can pull
    these weeds by standing over them and pressing B.  Sometimes they are
    hard to see, but I'm almost positive that weeds generally won't appear in
    a place that you can not see them.  They may be behind a tree, so you can
    peek around the sides of trees to check (scroll left or right but still look
    at the trees about to scroll off screen), but they should never be behind
    a big building like Nookington's.
    You can also get rid of weeds by completing a certain condition with a
    certain character in the middle of the night, but I won't discuss that here.
    If you are thorough enough to have obtained perfect condition, hopefully you
    can stand running through each acre in the town and checking for weeds (I
    actually think it's fun!).
    If you end up with lots of weeds in your town, the well will actually
    complain about it, which is something I hadn't seen until time-travelling
    forward to gain tons of weeds (great for experimentation).  I experimented
    with my 50+ weeds carefully, and learned a lot, but I don't have it all
    totally firmed up.  The conclusions I made should be good enough for a while,
    though, as we already know that having weeds is generally bad and you should
    get rid of them.
    The well directed me to several acres that had 4 or more weeds in them.
    After reducing any one of those acres to only 3 weeds, it would stop
    complaining about that one.  However, it stopped telling me to go to specific
    acres (instead, it gave me the general "Things aren't too bad" message) while
    there were still a few acres with four or more weeds in them.  This is what
    gave me the impression that the well
    After reducing those acres such that no acre in my whole town had more than
    three weeds in it, the well switched from the "almost satisfactory" message
    (see The Well's Messages above) to the "satisfactory" message (a surprising
    I tried reducing each acre to a maximum of two weeds each, but it wasn't
    until the total number of weeds lowered to 30 that the well said I had a
    perfect town.  At that point, some acres had two weeds, some had one, and
    some had zero.
    So here's my conclusions: 30 weeds is the maximum allowable total, 3 weeds
    per acre is the maximum allowable for satisfactory condition, and it seems
    that 2 weeds is the maximum allowable for perfect condition.  Unfortunately,
    by the time my town had 30 weeds in it, every square had below 3 weeds, so
    it's possible that 3 is allowed for perfect condition, but I'm not sure.
    Just as with dead tree sprouts (see below), the bottom line is that weeds are
    no good, so get rid of them as early and as often as possible.
    Dead Tree Sprouts as Weeds
    After planting many trees to achieve perfect condition, it's common to have
    many of the "sprouts" fail the next day.  By "failing", I mean that the tiny
    tree will have drooping leaves and a little round circle taken out of one of
    the leaves (presumably decay or damage from bugs eating it).
    I'm almost positive now that dead tree sprouts count as weeds.  If you have
    more than 3 of them in an acre, the well will probably complain about it.
    If it doesn't, I believe it's because of the well's "looseness" when it comes
    to telling you about weed problems (see Weeds above).
    Whether this is for sure or not, the bottom line is that I strongly recommend
    that you dig up failed sprouts if you are going for perfect condition, as
    having them around can only be detrimental.
    Make sure to read my "definition" of trash above for a clarification of what
    I'm talking about.  It's OK in the well's eyes to have some normal items lying
    around, but not OK to have trash lying around.  ** This includes the dump **.
    You can put trash in the dump and it will be taken away eventually (I stand
    corrected on this issue), but the well doesn't seem to make an exception for
    the dump--I'm almost positive (confirmation soon) that it will reset your
    perfect condition for trash to be in the dump.
    The best thing to do with trash is to "sell" it (read: give it) to Tom Nook.
    Some say that you can correct the "not enough trees" condition by planting
    flowers. This seems possible, but I have neither discovered a specific
    formula for it, nor have I confirmed it.  I recommend following the formula
    (between 9 and 16, inclusive) for the right number of trees, and then
    planting flowers where you see fit afterwards.  Also, I'm almost positive
    that you can not receive the "too many trees" message by planting too many
    flowers--I had twenty or so in an acre with 16 trees and had no problem.
    Of course, I haven't filled the screen with flowers ever, but that could
    take a long time to test.  (...might look pretty cool, though!)
    My guess is that if flowers can push the condition from "there is little
    green" to satisfactory condition "yes, yes...", then there is at least a
    rough formula for how many flowers it takes.
    Along with the story about my weeds experiment, the following story about
    my flowers experiment makes up a very important part of this update.  I
    counted 63 flowers in my town before touching them at all.  During this
    experiment, I kept three flower bags on hand and demolished three flowers at
    a time uniformly across my landscape, and checked the well each time to see
    if my town fell out of perfect condition.
    I never had to use those three flower bags I had on hand, as I demolished
    -every- single flower in my landscape.
    I still had perfect condition.
    This confirms that flowers are completely unnecessary for maintaining a
    perfect condition.  It's still possible that flowers are necessary or at
    least helpful for -obtaining- perfect, but I'm still not sure.
    Ver. 1.2 (11/04)--I think flowers suggest that a scoring system exists
    perhaps more than any other single factor.  Some people swear that planting
    flowers fixed their town, and I believe it to be possible, but I also know
    that flowers aren't required.  Thus they are "helpful" but not mandatory.
    SECTION III:             Getting the Golden Axe
    Keep it up!
    So your town is perfect?  Great!  Now it's time to try to keep it that way!
    In order to get the Golden Axe, you must maintain a perfect condition for 15
    days (confirmed by Atticus676 and the Nintendo Power Official Players Guide).
    In order to "maintain", it's best to play every day.  It's possible to not
    play for several days and keep perfect, but it's risky, because if you happen
    to get over 3 weeds in a given acre (won't happen after one day, but could
    happen after two or more days), then your town will fall out of perfect
    condition.  It's highly unlikely that it will happen in two days, but as I've
    said before, it's best to stay on top of it as much as you can.  Also, make
    sure to follow the tips at the end of Section II for getting rid of trash.
    The Well-Deserved Reward
    (The pun/reference to the wishing well was initially quite unintentional)
    ************* Possible Spoiler Alert!!! *************
    If you keep up the good work long enough, the next player to talk to the well
    will be visited by the well spirit, Farley.  The reward will be the Golden
    Axe! The Golden Axe is unbreakable, just like the Golden Shovel (thanks to
    CubeCrazyMonkey, Atticus, the Nintendo Power Guide, and others for
    SECTION IV:                 SPECULATION Central
    New or Unconfirmed SPECULATION
    -Ver 1.2 (11/4)
    SPECULATION: You need at least a certain number of -total- trees in your
    town to achieve perfect.
    Thanks for all the suggestions (Michael L., Vanda B. and others) on this one--
    I think this could be tied in to many people's problems with achieving
    perfect.  This may or may not replace the minimum requirement for trees in
    an exempt acre, as well.  If anyone can figure out the exact number, let
    me know.  I'll work on it as soon as I can.
    SPECULATION: Some or all of the beach acres are not exempt, or have special
    I know that this is at least partly true.  Many people on the boards and in
    e-mail have let me know that they've solved their problems by planting trees
    in some or all of the beach squares.  I'm not sure what the details are of
    this yet--let me know if you have ideas.  (Thanks to Steve P. and others for
    this topic)
    SPECULATION: The perfect condition is based on a "scoring" system and not
    a checklist.
    I have no hard evidence to confirm or deny this, but I believe in it
    wholeheartedly.  Many people have said that they've completed the checklist
    but don't have a perfect town.  Some of these people later acheived perfect
    towns through replanting trees, planting flowers, or one of many other
    "fixes".  This really does suggest a scoring system as opposed to a
    Any detailed info anyone can come up with for the scoring system would be
    -highly- appreciated.  See contact info below.
    SPECULATION: Your town must have under a certain amount of adjacent trees
    to achieve perfect status.
    Note that there was formerly a guideline in the checklist saying that you
    must have -no- adjacent trees.  Several readers have said that they have
    a few adjacent trees and have a perfect town, and I've confirmed that to be
    possible.  I do think that they affect the condition negatively, though.
    -Ver 1.1 (10/23)
    SPECULATION: According to BlueYoshi, flowers may divert the well's attention
    to another square if the square they are in is lacking something.  It's very
    hard to confirm this, but it's a feasible and neat idea boot.  Keep it in
    SPECULATION: The well doesn't always look at all the squares.
    BlueYoshi's idea about the flowers would support this.  Also, some readers
    are convinced that certain squares that I think are exempt are non-exempt.
    Since I've researched my theories on exempt squares quite thoroughly, I could
    chalk this up to the well not looking at my squares properly.  However, it
    seems more likely to me that there is a certain tree requirement even for
    exempt squares (say, a minimum of 1 tree).
    Also, the way the well didn't specifically point out some squares that had
    more than three weeds in my town (after I fixed a few that it did point out)
    suggests that the Well's sight may be imperfect.
    It is worth noting that this SPECULATION may never be fully confirmed or
    denied, but once again, it's good to keep in mind.  One of the most valuable
    things in working towards a perfect town is to be well-informed.
    Confirmed or Denied SPECULATION
    -Ver 1.2 (11/4)
    SPECULATION: Having trees up against cliffs, fences or buildings will
    keep you from having a perfect town.
    DENIED: I have several trees in all of these supposedly "bad" places, and I
    still have a perfect town.  However, they may have a negative effect (if
    there is indeed some sort of scoring system)...
    SPECULATION: You must not have any adjacent trees in order to have a perfect
    DENIED: This used to be part of my checklist.  It is totally false, and
    confirmed as such.  See above in the new speculation for more details.
    SPECULATION: A certain number of HRA points are required for perfect status.
    DENIED: I got as low of a HRA score as was possible (about 1,000) by removing
    everything in my house and "unmatching" the wallpaper and carpets.  I still
    had a perfect town.
    This is not to say that HRA -doesn't affect- the condition at all--only that
    it's not required.
    SPECULATION: Half grown trees keep your town from being perfect.
    DENIED: I have at least 5 in my town, and they neither kept me from
    achieving perfect nor made me lose perfect when I got more.
    -Ver 1.1 (10/23)
    SPECULATION: You must have no more than 10 weeds in your town for perfect
    DENIED: Several readers have confirmed that they have more than 10 weeds
    and remain in perfect condition.  I started at 50+ weeds and removed them in
    small batches until finding that 30 is the true maximum number (see checklist
    SPECULATION: Dead Tree Sprouts count towards the total number of weeds.
    OLD ANSWER: The problem with this assertion is that after getting rid of about 10 (of
    many) dead tree sprouts, I achieved perfect condition again, but I still had
    over 30 left.  This means that either a) dead sprouts count as a fraction of
    a weed or b) there is a separate counter for dead sprouts and hence a
    separate limit for them.  Unfortunately, the specifics of this speculation
    are extremely hard to confirm, but I'll be working on it.
    NEW ANSWER: See above under Dead Tree Sprouts as Weeds.
    SPECULATION: The golden axe is unbreakable.
    CONFIRMED: The only reason it was speculation was that I hadn't gotten it
    yet.  This has been confirmed by many, including the well spirit himself.
    SECTION V:                              Wrap Up
    Thanks to Nintendo for this awesome game!  I'd like to make a special mention
    of the quality of the localization--for anyone who understands Japanese or who
    has studied it, there are lots of great touches, such as how the shop owner,
    a Tanuki (somewhat of a Japanese raccoon) is named Tom Nook, the Kapp'n is a
    Japanese sea critter called a Kappa (get it?), etc.  Not only that, but the
    writing is great!  It obviously goes far and beyond a straight translation.
    Thanks to GameFAQs for hosting both this FAQ and a great site that I
    appreciate more each day.  Without the help of those on the message boards,
    I could not have created this.  Thanks also to Neoseeker for their interest
    in this FAQ.
    Thanks to my roommates (Ants Eames and Jenny Becker) for playing along and for
    tolerating long hours spent messing with trees (not the most fun thing to
    witness, I'm sure). Thanks also to Bobby Conover and Brett Camper for enjoying
    this game with me in the early days of it's release, as well as for chatting
    about it on-line.
    Thanks to everyone who has answered my posts on the message boards (Animal
    Crossing and otherwise), and to GameFAQs for hosting such a great site.
    Thanks to all who contribute to this community, and to all those writing
    detailed FAQs for this unusual game.
    Thanks to the writers of the many FAQs I have read--they have shaped the
    writing of this guide without a doubt.  Any similarities of this guide to
    other guides (besides the traditional structuring and other conventions)
    is unintentional.
    Big Thanks to all of the reader feedback and suggestions--you guys are going
    to help me make this a much better guide.  Thanks to (real names and
    e-mail names are intermixed) BlueYoshi579, CubeCrazyMonkey, Kevin W.,
    Casey J., Aldrin N., Atticus676, CHester, Tom K. in Canadia,
    Adam P., Andrew G., Rob R., Cutter Kwan, Danny L., Duane A. and Steve,
    Danman008, Danny L., David N., Eric S., Erick B., Graham K., Jason M., Jodi W.,
    Mangraa, Hou-en L., Michael L., SXesteve, Steve P., SkulDrgn, Robert P.,
    Qiksilver311, NJ Layne, Phillip R., Charizard2000, Jonathan S., and many
    others.  (If your name appears in this thank you list in a way other than
    how you want it (people may or may not want there full name listed), let
    me know.)
    A Big "No Thanks" goes out to the viruses that are coming my way--please,
    please, use an anti virus program to scan your computer before contacting me.
    Many more thanks to come--hopefully for some great submissions!
    Copyrights, etc.
    This guide is:
    Copyright 2002 Brendan McCracken/elumelum.
    All trademarks and copyrights contained in this document are owned by their
    respective trademark and copyright holders.
    DO NOT sell, distribute, or reproduce this guide for any purpose without
    contacting me.  This guide is my work and my property, and I do not approve
    of ANY unauthorized copying or distribution--especially not plagiarism.
    Please do not post this FAQ on your web site without contacting me first.
    Write me a polite e-mail and I'll be glad to assist you.  This FAQ is
    currently authorized to be posted on GameFAQs and Neoseeker.
    Hope you've gotten help or at least satisfaction out of this guide!  See ya
    next update.

    View in: