Hi Everyone
Here is the updated list. I want to give a thanks to EgoKiller801 for resurrecting the topic in my absence. The way this works is simple. You vote for your top 10 genesis games. #1 gets 10 points down to #10 which gets 1 point. The original topic was for only 5 votes, but this has been expanded. Because of this you can vote again if you haven't voted since the topic was expanded. On to the list!
1. Sonic the Hedgehog 2 - 922(57)
2. Gunstar Heroes - 503(35)
3. Streets of Rage II - 499(29)
4. Sonic 3 & Knuckles - 472(41)
5. Phantasy Star IV - 440(37)
6. Shining Force II - 395(25)
7. Sonic the Hedgehog - 362(13)
8. Shining Force - 308(20)
9. Sonic the Hedgehog 3 - 250(18)
10. ToeJam & Earl - 216(13)
11. Shinobi III: Return of the Ninja Master - 207(12)
12. Castlevania: Bloodlines - 206(3)
13. Sonic & Knuckles - 200(7)
14. Streets of Rage - 185
15. Rocket Knight Adventures - 165(6)
16. Contra: Hard Corps - 149(4)
17. LandStalker - 124(12)
17. Ristar - 124(2)
19. Phantasy Star II - 123(7)
20. Vectorman - 121(6)
21. Lightening Force: Quest for the Darkstar - 114(7)
22. Dynamite Headdy - 111(11)
23. Comix Zone - 100(4)
24. Golden Axe - 98(3)
25. Pirates! Gold - 95(6)
26. NHL Hockey - 94(6)
27. Revenge of Shinobi - 93(3)
28. General Chaos - 83(8)
29. Shadowrun - 81(4)
30. Alien Soldier - 80(6)
31. Road Rash II - 77(3)
32. Streets of Rage 3 - 76(1)
33. Street Fighter II': Special Champion Edition - 71(4)
34. MUSHA: Metallic Uniframe Super Hybrid Armor - 70(3)
35. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: The Hyperstone Heist - 64(2)
36. Super Street Fighter II - 63(5)
37. Kid Chameleon - 62(5)
38. Mortal Kombat II - 56 (1)
39. StarFlight - 54(2)
39. Zombies Ate My Neighbors - 54(4)
41. Beyond Oasis - 51(2)
42. Road Rash - 47(1)
43. Crusader of Centy - 46
43. Dr. Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine - 46(2)
45. Ghouls 'n Ghosts - 43(5)
46. Earthworm Jim - 41(1)
47. Mortal Kombat - 40(3)
48. Mega Bomberman - 39(1)
49. Disney's Aladdin - 38(1)
49. Herzog Zwei - 38(3)
51. Wonder Boy in Monster World - 36
52. El Viento - 35(2)
52. Flashback: The Quest for Identity - 35(1)
52. Virtua Racing - 35
55. Ecco the Dolphin - 33
55. OutRun - 33(1)
55. Strider - 33
55. Yuu Yuu Hakusho: Makyo Toitsusen - 33(4)
59. Golden Axe II - 32
59. Thunder Force III - 32(1)
59. World of Illusion Starring Mickey Mouse & Donald Duck - 32(2)
62. Ecco: The Tides of Time - 31(1)
62. Ranger X - 31
62. Star Control - 31(2)
65. Mutant League Football - 29(1)
65. Shining in the Darkness - 29
65. Toejam & Earl in Panic on Funkotron - 29(2)
65. Warsong - 29
69. Cool Spot - 28
69. Phantasy Star III: Generations of Doom - 28(2)
71. Monster World IV - 26 (3)
71. Shadow Dancer - 26(2)
73. Forgotten Worlds - 25 (1)
73. Jungle Strike - 25
73. Micro Machines Turbo Tournament 96 - 25
73. Quackshot: Starring Donald Duck - 25
77. John Madden Football - 24
77. Michael Jackson's Moonwalker - 28(4)
77. Sonic the Hedgehog Spinball - 24(2)
80. Desert Strike: Return to the Gulf - 23
80. Sunset Riders - 23(1)
80. Ultimate Mortal Kombat 3 - 23
83. Altered Beast - 22(1)
83. Gaiares - 22(2)
83. Rock 'N Roll Racing - 22(1)
86. Eternal Champions - 21
86. Jurassic Park - 21
88. Mega Man: The Wily Wars - 20(2)
88. NBA Jam Tournament Edition - 20
88. NBA Live - 20
88. Warriors of the Eternal Sun - 20(3)
92. Boogerman: A Pick and Flick Adventure - 19(1)
92. King's Bounty: The Conqueror's Quest - 19
92. Panorama Cotton - 19(2 )
92. Sonic 3D Blast - 19(1)
96. Ghostbusters - 18(2)
96. Vectorman 2 - 18
98. Golden Axe III - 17(2)
98. Splatterhouse 3 - 17(1)
98. Truxton - 17 (1)
http://www.gamefaqs.com/features/mygames/collection