• Post New Message
You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. Sign Up for free (or Log In if you already have an account) to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts.
  1. Boards
  2. Fire Emblem: Three Houses
  3. What did Feral Dimitri do? That's comparable to Rhea or Edelgard?

User Info: A_Field_Lover

A_Field_Lover
1 week ago#31
bookwormbabe29 posted...
You're free to defend your favorite child murdered all you want. You asked what he did wrong. I posted he killed kids, and posted pics. If killing kids is ok with you, that's your problem. For me, that's a deal breaker.

As to being naive? Get over yourself, kid. You're out of league here.
"H-He killed kids!!!1"

>Fodlan has an entire issue of child soldiers and children are wildin in current war Fodlan. The same kids in Garreg Mach trying to attack Dimitri

"Shut up that doesn't count he KILLED KIDS"

By that logic everyone in Fodlan's a child murderer at this point, because kids are raised to fight and do s*** at a ridiculously young age in Fodlan.
Nerd girl who's passionate, Bandana Dee for Smash!
#1 Assist Trophy, Galeem, Lonato & FE Echoes Lover! F to Geno, BWD + Isaac. Hero's in!

User Info: Tluhdatsi

Tluhdatsi
1 week ago#32
Since he talks about not really having a sense of taste in some supports, I'm kind of glad they don't go into too much detail about what sort of stuff he was eating during this phase. It could be pretty much any disgusting thing you can imagine.
With a thrill in my head and a pill on my tongue, dissolving the nerves has just begun.
Listening to Lionel, All Night Long, (all night), yeeeah, (all night)...
(edited 1 week ago)

User Info: A_Field_Lover

A_Field_Lover
1 week ago#33
rukn posted...
Dimitri murders people in a crap state of mind to satisfy the ghosts in his head. He was torture happy for half a decade. He suicide runs his family and friends into imperial troops. And he has like no justification no rationale, he just indulges his sadism. Dude has been born with super powers, and once he decides you are bad he can do whatever the hell he wants to your body, no justification necessary, because he is such an entitled brat.

He does nothing that would recommend him to leadership but you are basically going ‘I like this man on a personal level he deserves to be king’, he eats up everything in his story, everyone’s story is less important than his. He hasn’t suffered anymore than Dedue or Edelgard but the story seems to insist that his reaction is somehow acceptable because the dude started seeing dead people. Felix’s dad’s death becomes all about his reaction to it, the event of Duscur becomes all about how he lost people the story doesn’t particularly care abt exploring the punishment.

With Edelgard you have to argue whether her rationale for going to war was right or wrong , with Dimitri his only rationale is ‘Edelgard bad’ hell even by the end it seems his philosophy is just ‘not Edelgard’ because otherwise he sees nothing wrong in taking over the entire continent and imposing his ideals on people. He is basically one of those annoying fantasy types who barely face consequences, have no obvious political skills or vision, but ‘deserve’ a throne.
>Somehow acceptable

Stopped reading there. Dimitri himself says he doesn't deserve happiness and his own childhood friends ((Sylvain at a monastery convo) admit that he's wrong and that they won't forget what he did.
Nerd girl who's passionate, Bandana Dee for Smash!
#1 Assist Trophy, Galeem, Lonato & FE Echoes Lover! F to Geno, BWD + Isaac. Hero's in!

User Info: Mxylbobator

Mxylbobator
1 week ago#34
bookwormbabe29 posted...
You asked what he did wrong. I posted he killed kids, and posted pics.


You're also being intentionally misleading, because it was obvious that what he said in his A support (with Byleth) is tied to his statement, along with the fact that child soldiers are a thing in this war. The fact that you are so hooked to Dimitri killing commoners without realizing that Imperial soldiers were both commoners and nobles shows that you just want to hate on him.
(edited 1 week ago)
Take into account Dimitri is the only one (besides Metodley, or whatever his name is) that takes pleasure from killing. The way he's overly brutal to his 'enemies' (real or imagined) is shown. He could have killed two kids or 2 hundred in this brutal fashion, we do not know, and the fact that every defender of his tries to justify child murder as that one time, and that it's ok because they were BAD KIDS, tells you all that you need to know about him, and this community.

On the plus side, topics like these help weed out the trolls.
3DS Friend Code: 0920-2538-1864
Pokemon Sun IGN: Kala

User Info: Mxylbobator

Mxylbobator
1 week ago#36
bookwormbabe29 posted...
He could have killed two kids or 2 hundred in this brutal fashion, we do not know,


The only kids (who were likely the same age as students pre-timeskip) that we know he killed were in self-defense. Everything else is just your headcanon.

bookwormbabe29 posted...
the fact that every defender of his tries to justify child murder as that one time, and that it's ok because they were BAD KIDS, tells you all that you need to know about him, and this community.


Pretty obvious that you are the troll at this point if you actually believe this. What's next, are you going to say it's wrong to outright kill bandits, which has always been a thing with the Fire Emblem series?

User Info: DOTBHDD

DOTBHDD
1 week ago#37
Mxylbobator posted...
bookwormbabe29 posted...
He could have killed two kids or 2 hundred in this brutal fashion, we do not know,


The only kids (who were likely the same age as students pre-timeskip) that we know he killed were in self-defense. Everything else is just your headcanon.

bookwormbabe29 posted...
the fact that every defender of his tries to justify child murder as that one time, and that it's ok because they were BAD KIDS, tells you all that you need to know about him, and this community.


Pretty obvious that you are the troll at this point if you actually believe this. What's next, are you going to say it's wrong to outright kill bandits, which has always been a thing with the Fire Emblem series?

Kids were killed by that man
Remember to attempt showing empathy online over sympathy and apathy. The internet can't solve your mental health issues.

User Info: uberking422

uberking422
1 week ago#38
Mxylbobator posted...
You're also being intentionally misleading, because it was obvious that what he said in his A support (with Byleth) is tied to his statement, along with the fact that child soldiers are a thing in this war. The fact that you are so hooked to Dimitri killing commoners without realizing that Imperial soldiers were both commoners and nobles shows that you just want to hate on him.
Seriously. Do people think the empire's bajillion troops that they used to overwhelm the monastery grew out of a f***ing cabbage patch or something?
#39
(message deleted)

User Info: Stepdog

Stepdog
1 week ago#40
Poison-puffs posted...
uberking422 posted...
Seriously. Do people think the empire's bajillion troops that they used to overwhelm the monastery grew out of a f***ing cabbage patch or something?
What’s funny is the same people that say Dimitri murdered and killed innocents are surprisingly silent when Edelgard and the Empire do the exact same thing. It’s just bias


Can you not derail another thread with your Edelgard hate. The title of the thread already established that TC believes that she and Rhea are bad people. The question is if Dimitri is as well, that’s why people mention him specifically killing children.
  1. Boards
  2. Fire Emblem: Three Houses
  3. What did Feral Dimitri do? That's comparable to Rhea or Edelgard?
  • Post New Message