4 days ago #6
I actually think the harder part for me to believe is that she still had so much pent up anger that she would travel across the country, risking herself and all her friends to brutally murder a man she's never met over something that happened 4-5 years ago.

Anger dwindles with time, particularly if you've never even seen this person you're after, nor did you directly witness their crime. This narrative makes it feel like what Joel did just happened, and Abby hasn't grown or accepted it whatsoever since then, which is very difficult for me to believe.