• Topic Archived
You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. Sign Up for free (or Log In if you already have an account) to be able to post messages, change how messages are displayed, and view media in posts.
  1. Boards
  2. Shenmue
  3. This game was the first of 16 chapters?

User Info: Mazryonh

Mazryonh
8 years ago#1
If indeed the entire, uncut, and unabridged Shenmue series was to span 16 games the length and breadth of Shenmue 1, how on earth did Yu Suzuki think he would have financed all 16 games, and on an underperforming system like the Dreamcast?

Sometimes I'm confused as to whether Yu Suzuki was lacking in the pragmatism department. No one bats an eye when a famous author decides to write a 16-volume epic fantasy novel (and perhaps the best chance for an uncut Shenmue saga would be in a literary form), because as long as the author can support him/herself, then the only thing being consumed is the author's own time and effort. But 16 games the length and breadth of Shenmue 1? How did he ever think Sega would ever finance that many on an untried method of gaming?

There's also the issue of whether players could put up with all this. Would fans of Shenmue really have the patience to play through a second Shenmue game that didn't take place in Hong Kong, but instead on the boat to Hong Kong (the supposed original setting for the second game), and by the end of the game didn't let you get off there but only rolled the credits? Would you feel that you had been led on to false reward? I personally am not sure I would have stuck around for that long.

Another instance of Shenmue's problems if it had followed Yu Suzuki's original layout would be how late you get to see Yuanda Zhu to hear him explain the purpose behind the mirrors. Apparently the final version of Shenmue 2 is actually Chapters 3, 4, 5--if you had to wait to play 3 different games before seeing Yuanda Zhu and having him explain the purpose behind the mirrors, would you have bought that many games and stuck around that long?
An Angel yet sleeps / The stars await their savior / The Nexus shines still.
http://youtu.be/BhZQEvg1V0Y

User Info: zeleny

zeleny
8 years ago#2
Obviously, Yu Suzuki and Sega didn't anticipate the commercial failure of the series. Had the game been more popular among the masses, funding would not be so much of an issue and we would most likely have seen this game progress till the very end. As it stands, the chances of seeing a sequel grow slimmer by the year. Looking back, I would have started the game in the most interesting chapters (maybe mid-way through) and work on prequels (chapters 1-5 / present day Shenmue I & II) to grow a bigger audience / fan base.

I agree it'd be best to see his work continued in another form (anime, manga, etc.).
http://www.youtube.com/azmune
#3
(message deleted)

User Info: sonicknuckles2k

sonicknuckles2k
8 years ago#4
Keep in mind that Shenmue and Shenmue II were originally meant to be one whole game.

IDK if they're still up, but Gamespot had previews of Kowloon back in 1999.

User Info: Duh_Bad_Guy

Duh_Bad_Guy
8 years ago#5
No. Each game ended up spanning 4 chapters.

Shenmue 1. Chapter 1-4
shenmue 2. Chapter 5-8 (chapter 8 was supposed to be the beginning of shenmue 3 but was added into part 2. Great move because it was the most boring part of the game)
shenmue 3 chapters 9-12.
Shenmue 4 chapters 13-16
"An eye for an eye ass wipe. A toof, for a gotdamn toof." -Buffalo Soldier

User Info: Vyse_skies

Vyse_skies
8 years ago#6
Duh, don't make me cry :( I needed one extra game, but two games to complete the saga sounds like a pipe-nightmare. I want them now :( And I want to play that excluded chapter two so I can kick Chai's ass again.
Because poem interpretation is ambiguous, when a poet's shoddiest works are criticised his failsafe merely states that the reader doesn't understand.

User Info: Duh_Bad_Guy

Duh_Bad_Guy
8 years ago#7
Tell me about broseph. Shenmue 3 is so far away. Sega will either incorporate the remaining chapters into shenmue 3 or see how good 3 does in sales and determine if 4 should see light.

Pisses me off, Yakuza is great but not better than shenmue and there's 5.
"An eye for an eye ass wipe. A toof, for a gotdamn toof." -Buffalo Soldier
#8
(message deleted)

User Info: Duh_Bad_Guy

Duh_Bad_Guy
8 years ago#9
Yuffie4life posted...
Did you just call him Duh?


Lmao I just noticed that. You can call me DBG.
"An eye for an eye ass wipe. A toof, for a gotdamn toof." -Buffalo Soldier

User Info: FatalFragger

FatalFragger
8 years ago#10
I don't recall ever hearing that the boat was supposed to be an entire game...just a deleted chapter.
  1. Boards
  2. Shenmue
  3. This game was the first of 16 chapters?
  • Topic Archived

Need More Help?

  1. Guides and Walkthroughs 37 Guides / Maps
  2. GameFAQs Q&A 7 Questions (7 Answered)

GameFAQs Q&A