Subjective, for example this person even made a thread about it https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/191635-marvels-spider-man/77338869 Showing some people weren't swayed till the ending
You're right about it being subjective, but in the thread you linked, the majority of posters didn't state anything along the lines of what you've said. Only the topic creator and one other person within.
Hell, the topic creator even retracts their initial statement of the story being "s***ty":
I mean s***ty may not have been the right word
The Official Robin of the I2 Boards The Official Ermac of the MK11 Boards