Personally I did just like you, and played TFBW first then got interested in Stick of truth and bought it too. Personally I Enjoy the Simpler Mechanics of stick more, and the story and comedy is IMHO much greater in stick of truth. Neither game is actually bad in my opinion, both are worth a play through, especially if you’re a South Park fan that alone makes the games worth it. And given the division between others who have answered, I guess it has a lot to do with your style and personal preferences which you may like more or how much you would like one or the other. But despite being older Stick of truth holds up beautifully (and frankly makes the beginning of the second game make a lot more sense). Personally The ONLY issues that stick suffers from, and TFBW does better (and they’re really trivial in the grand scheme), are the DLC and The version of South Park in the first game is a bit dated if you stayed up with the show. Things like SoDoSoPa the whole PC craze and its characters are absent and a lot of other South Park staples are absent (Raisins, Skeeters Wine Bar, the Italian Restaurant, the Pot Store, Mephestos Lab, Peppermint Hippo & Counting DLC Casa Bonita and The Special Needs Camp). And the first game……technically has some DLC, but it’s in the form of some cool looking costumes/equipment that you get at the beginning of the game, and they look pretty cool and actually have some useful perks, but they’re all extremely low level and you won’t actually use them for more than the first 30 to 45 minutes before you start getting gear that way outclasses them, I don’t know why they chose to do it like that but they did. There is no additional story or extra levels or anything to actually add significant content to the game like TFBW had. But I would still 100% absolutely recommend playing it, The only other thing it suffers from is even if you do all of the side quests….It’s fairly short for an RPG and you can get to max level fairly fast, and it’s just a little over half as long if you do no side questing, but that means you don’t have to invest a lot of time to play, and if for some reason you don’t really enjoy it you won’t have to waste a lot of valuable playtime to get into the game and at least enjoy the story…Plus if someone else sorry pointed out one other big benefit is it can be bought pretty cheap at this point…I got it on The PlayStation Store(PS4) for $9.99, and you can get the DLC for free by making/linking an Ubisoft account in the game menu. So either way even if you don’t like it it’s not a huge time or money sink,But I don’t think any actual South Park fan would actually hate or not enjoy the game whatsoever. The first game is sort of like playing an entire season of South Park with one single story arc.